Whether you cave for mouth watering saucy pasta, delicious spaghetti sauce or aromatically roasted meat; we bring in for you a bunch of Italian restaurants that have been critically acclaimed for offering the most genuine experience of indulging in traditional cuisine from Italy. The best thing about these eateries is that they are experts in blending original recipes with modern flavours to create some innovative gastronomy. Though few of them might sound expensive, their impeccably prepared items demands a “must try”. Thus scroll further to identify the best Italian restaurants in NYC.
Top Ten Italian Restaurants in New York City
Mentioned below are the top ten Italian restaurants in New York City that have been offering the most authentic Italian dining ambience to the city that never sleep.
1. Il Giglio
Popular for items such as Dover sole, osso buco, double-cut veal chop, spaghetti carbonara and sublime cheesecake; Il Giglio is one of the most well accepted Italian restaurants among the New Yorkers. The eatery might be a little expensive but nobody seems to mind it due to its diversity in traditional Italian cuisine. Moreover its outstanding service and experienced presentation makes it a favourite among the food lovers of the metropolis.
The restaurant is located at 81 Warren Street between West Broadway and Greenwich St. in Lower Manhattan, New York City. Please call 212-571-5555.
2. Osteria Morini
To treat your taste buds with handmade pastas, heart throbbing meat and potatoes suffused in pan drippings by the most prolific Italian-American chef – Michael White, Osteria Morini is a must visit. The fact that it introduces New York to the soulful cookeries of the Emilia-Romagna region of Italy makes it the most authentic Italian restaurant in NYC. Located on Petrosino Square, the 98-seat restaurant was named after Michael’s tutor – Gianluigi Morini.
Osteria Morini is situated at – 218 Lafayette Street, New York, NY 10012, United States. You can call: +1 212-965-8777.
Scarpetta’s season-inspired Italian recipes blended with farm fresh ingredients are the reason behind why it is a part of the top 10 Italian restaurants in New York City. Sited in the middle of the Meatpacking, the bistro serves as the pristine place for people looking out for romantic ambience accompanied by exceptional food and wide range of wine selection. Hard to get reservations, it is advisable to book the restaurant in advance.
Warm and modern Scarpetta is located at – 355 W 14th Street, New York, NY 10014, United States. Phone: +1 212-691-0555.
Carbone, situated at Greenwich Village is the brainchild of Mario Carbone, Jeff Zalaznick and Rich Torrisi. Its remarkably well prepared food together with comfy, classy and unpretentious setting links it back to the mid 20th century authentic Italian restaurants in New York. Seafood Salad, Lobster Fra Diavola, Veal Parmesan, Linguini Vongole etc are few of its historic menus prepared with contemporary touch.
This Italian-American restaurant is situated at – 181 Thompson St, New York, NY 10012, United States. Phone: +1 212-254-3000
5. Salumeria Rosi
A perfect example of “tiny-space efficiency”, Salumeria Rosi Parmacotto is a joint venture between the Italian meat maestro, Parmacotta and the ex-Maremma chef Cesare Casella. Apart from the rustic food, its intimate and cosy ambience is something that draws majority of its visitors. Salumeria Rosi is well known for keeping up pace with everyday Italian life within the boundaries of New York City.
New York locates one of the top Italian restaurants at- 283 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10023, United States. Phone: +1 212-877-4800
6. Il Buco
While seeking out for an authentic Italian restaurant in NYC, Il Buco is one that shares its space among the highly recommended list. Maximum of the items prepared out of Olive oil, its menu tends to keep changing as per the change in season. Besides, it also has a reputation for bearing the best wine menu in whole of New York. Here one can find everything starting from polenta with mushrooms and balsamic, Swiss chard and mustard to porchetta with lentils.
Detail of the restaurant is – 47 Bond St, Manhattan, NY 10012, United States. You can contact on- Phone: +1 212-533-1932
7. Trattoria L’incontro
With elegant decors and heavenly menu with roots in Italy, Trattoria L’incontro is a Michelin star Italian restaurant in NYC. Owned by head chef, Rocco Sacramone, the eatery is the apt place for treating special occasions. In fact it is the best Italian restaurant located in Queens with a laid-back yet classy atmosphere. From appetizer, salads, main course, wine to dessert; there is not a single item that can be ignored at this place.
The famous Italian restaurant in New York is located at- 21-76 31st St, Queens, NY 11105, United States. You can book your table on – Phone: +1 718-721-3532
8. Il Mulino
Il Mulino is the best Italian restaurant in NYC to head for indulging in impeccable and genuine cuisine from Abruzzo region of Italy. Located at upper East of New York, the bistro has remained true to its originality for the last two decades. Frequented by many upper class socialites, Il Mulino has been even awarded with a number of accolades during the past years.
The location of the restaurant is – 86 W 3rd St, New York, NY 10012, United States. Phone: +1 212-673-3783
Gifted with a real comprehension of high quality food and drink, Eataly offers a wide selection of finely blended Italian food. From buying a simple loaf of bread to engaging in a lavish dinner, the restaurant assures to be painstakingly honest in whatever they prepare. It happens to be a top Italian restaurant in 200 fifth Avenue, New York City.
Restaurant can be sited at – 200 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, Phone number- (646) 398-5100
10. Del Posto
The record of top 10 best Italian restaurants in NYC won’t be complete without mentioning Del Posto, situated at 85 tenth Avenue, NYC. With bona fide gastronomy, setting and service; it provides the exact express of traditional Italian dining experience in midst of American culture. The critically acclaimed restaurant is the creation of Joe Bastianich and Mario Batali.
Del Posto is located at – 85 10th Ave (btwn 15th & 16th St), New York, NY 10011. You can contact at the phone no. : (212) 497-809